Human Sexuality

Soc./Psych. 160, Fall 2003

Killing the Black Body Essay Assignment

 

 

Book: Killing the Black Body by Dorothy Roberts; available at A Room of One’s Own bookstore (On Johnson just south of State Street)

 

Due: Week of October 13th IN YOUR SECTION

 

Length: 4-5 pages (no more than 2000 words), typed, double-spaced, in 12 pt. Times New Roman or similar font, black ink only, 1” margins (we mean it!)

 

Grading Scale: worth 50 points

 

The goals of this paper are: 1) to help you gain web literacy in choosing and deciphering between sources; 2) To be able to use more than one source to come to your own conclusion about something.

 

What to Do:

1.      Read the first 3 chapters of Killing the Black Body, paying attention to topics you find interesting. Choose one of these topics.

2.      Choose a website that talks about the topic you chose.

3.      Describe why the website you have chosen is a valid source of information – refer to the handout on evaluating web sites.

4.      Compare & contrast the content of the website with your choice of topic from Killing the Black Body, noting any differences or similarities in content, between the two sources. Then, describe how one source is more logical, uses more or better evidence, or uses more reliable evidence to make the argument.

5.      Submit your paper electronically to your TA and give your TA a hard copy of it in your section.

 

Paper FAQs

Q. What do you mean, “write a paper?What the hell is a paper? And what do you mean, “write?What is this “writing” nonsense you keep mentioning?

A. Drop this class now.

 

Q. It says here that we’re supposed to include citations. Um, what are citations?

A. Citations are just references to sources you’ve read. Keep in mind that your thesis statement should reflect two things: both your real, actual opinion, and your reading of the materials. These two are related! Your real, actual opinion should be developed from the materials that you’ve read, not in spite of it. As a result of that, you’re going to need to refer to those books or lectures from time to time. So any time you quote or paraphrase something from a source, you give credit to that source for the idea. This is how we do it!

 

Q. Do I then need a references page or bibliography?

A. Yes. It’s just a list of all the sources you’ve used in the paper. If you have questions about how to format the bibliography, ask your TA or visit the Writing Center’s website, http://www.wisc.edu/writing/.

 

Q. Do you care if I use footnotes, endnotes, or parenthetical citations?

A. No, just as long as you use one correctly  and stick with it throughout the paper. Don’t know what we mean by that? Visit the Writing Center’s website, http://www.wisc.edu/writing/.

 

Q. Are you going to be, like, checking for spelling and grammar and stuff?

A. Yep.

 

___________________________________________________________________

 

Checklist for Evaluating Web Sites

What?

WHAT is the site about? Does it have the kind of information you need?

  • Look at the browser title bar, document title, content and links.

Who?

WHO created the page/site? Can you find and verify the author's qualifications, whether an individual or an organization?

  • Look for "About the author/About us" links for author's name and contact information.
  • Verify author's qualifications in another source, e.g. journal, encyclopedia, directory, etc.
  • Look for a link to the home page of the Web site where the document lives.
  • Look at the parts of the URL or address to find organizational affiliation.

Where?

WHERE is the information coming from?

  • Look at the address or URL: e.g. .edu=educational, .com=commercial, .org=organization, .gov=government, two letter country codes.
  • Look up domain owner with WhoIs search (http://www.networksolutions.com/en_US/whois/index.jhtml)

Why?

WHY is this site on the web and how does it affect the information?

  • Look at "About us/Mission/Purpose", links, content and advertising.
  • Determine purpose of the site:
    • Advocacy or "soapbox" (tries to persuade).
    • Informational (often multiple viewpoints and references).
    • Business or marketing (tries to sell).
    • Entertainment.
  • Choose sites whose purposes are compatible with your information needs.

How?

HOW accurate or credible is the page?

  • Examine references and bibliographies.
  • Verify information in another reputable source (e.g. encyclopedia, journal, book, other Web site).
  • If you notice many errors in spelling, punctuation, grammar, etc., question accuracy of other information.

When?

WHEN was the page or information created? Is the date important for the timeliness of the content?

  • Look for dates. Can you tell what they mean? Publication or copyright date? Last modified or updated? Date statistics gathered or published?
  • Note date you accessed the site. You need this to cite the Web site!

Compiled by: University of Wisconsin-Madison Libraries Internet Workshop Working Group
The URL of this page is: http://www.library.wisc.edu/libraries/Instruction/instmat/webeval.htm
Last updated: August 1, 2003. If you have trouble accessing this page, please contact ckruse@library.wisc.edu